Compass Alternatives for Agents Who Want 100% Commission: How the Math Compares
Ask your broker one question today: what did the brokerage keep from my commissions last year? The answer is often larger than agents expect. Add it up, and it becomes the benchmark for every offer you consider.
A 100% commission model swaps that percentage for a flat fee. Whether the trade wins depends on your volume, the size of the fee, and what the fee includes. A low fee with no support can cost more than a high fee that saves you a deal.
This guide compares five New York brokerages that offer 100% commission with a traditional split. Compass is our reference point, but it does not publish a standard split. So we show the math as a formula you can run with your own numbers.
Five Compass alternatives at a glance
SPiRALNY charges a flat monthly brokerage fee on its 100% plan and includes mentorship, training, and direct broker access. McKee Realty publishes the lowest monthly fee here at $140. Mont Sky Real Estate charges $399 a month with E&O included and a lead program.
Royalux Realty charges $7,500 a year for its 100% plan. Alpha Properties NYC publishes a $499 monthly plan with per-transaction fees. Its page warns that some policies have changed.
Against a traditional split, all five can cost far less for an agent with real volume. Against each other, they differ widely. McKee and Mont Sky publish lower prices than SPiRALNY, so look at what each fee buys.
| Platform | Starting Price | Best For | Key Differentiator |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPiRALNY | $479/month ($399 plan, $25 E&O, $55 technology) plus $250 onboarding | Agents who want 100% plus support | Mentorship, training, direct broker access, and a Park → 90% → 100% path |
| McKee Realty | $140/month plus $200 onboarding | Cost-focused agents who self-source | Lowest published monthly fee; no transaction fees stated |
| Mont Sky Real Estate | $399/month, no startup fee | Agents who close two or more deals a year alone | E&O included; a lead program with no guaranteed volume |
| Royalux Realty | $7,500/year (Plan C) | Branding-minded producers | Branding services and about 200 hours of training |
| Alpha Properties NYC | $499/month plus $360 per rental and $1,000 per sale | Agents who want a desk in a small office | Boutique office; a second plan with a $100,000 threshold |
Prices come from each firm’s own pages, read on 20 October 2026 unless noted. Alpha’s figures come from our 2 October 2026 read and should be treated as stale. SPiRALNY’s checkout adds a 4% platform fee on the plan price and on onboarding.
How we compared them
We read each firm’s own pages and looked at the same seven items. These were recurring cost, transaction fees, caps, E&O, technology fees, onboarding fees, and support. Where a firm does not publish an item, we say so.
We also kept the list to firms that serve New York agents. Some operate in other states too. Pricing is a snapshot, so confirm every figure before you sign.
The math: your brokerage’s share versus a flat fee
The formula is short. Divide a flat annual fee by the share of each commission your brokerage keeps. The result is the gross commission at which the flat fee starts to win.
Take a brokerage that keeps 20%. A $5,998 first-year fee breaks even at $29,990 in gross commission. Above that number, the flat fee costs you less.
The table below runs that formula for each firm’s year-one fees. Pick the column closest to your current brokerage share.
| Firm (year-one fixed cost) | Brokerage keeps 10% | Brokerage keeps 20% | Brokerage keeps 30% |
|---|---|---|---|
| McKee ($1,880) | $18,800 | $9,400 | $6,267 |
| Mont Sky ($4,788) | $47,880 | $23,940 | $15,960 |
| SPiRALNY ($5,998) | $59,980 | $29,990 | $19,993 |
| Alpha Pro 1 ($5,988, before deal fees) | $59,880 | $29,940 | $19,960 |
| Royalux Plan C ($7,500) | $75,000 | $37,500 | $25,000 |
The table shows the gross commission needed to break even. SPiRALNY’s year-one cost rises to $6,237.92 with the 4% checkout fee. In year two, onboarding drops out and the cost is $5,748 before the card fee.
Now try an agent who grosses $150,000. A brokerage that keeps 20% takes $30,000, and one that keeps 30% takes $45,000. Here is what each 100% option costs in year one.
| Option | First-year cost at $150,000 gross commission |
|---|---|
| Brokerage keeps 20% (example) | $30,000 |
| Brokerage keeps 30% (example) | $45,000 |
| McKee 100% plan | $1,880 |
| Mont Sky 100% plan | $4,788 |
| SPiRALNY Platinum | $5,998 ($6,237.92 with card fee) |
| Royalux Plan C | $7,500 |
| Alpha Pro 1, four sales and six rentals | $12,148 ($5,988 plus $6,160 in deal fees) |
These splits are examples, not quotes. They exist to show the shape of the trade. Your own statement is the only number that settles it.
What the math leaves out
A spreadsheet cannot price everything. A strong brand, a listing platform, and a manager down the hall all have value. So do mentorship, training, and a broker who picks up the phone.
Put a number on what you would miss, then compare the net. An agent who closes ten deals a year from their own sphere may need very little help. An agent who still leans on guidance may value support above a lower fee.
Also count your time. Switching costs hours of paperwork and a few weeks of reset. Plan for both.
What we know about Compass
Compass does not publish a standard agent split in the sources we reviewed. In 2021, Inman published an estimate based on Compass’s filing.
It put commissions and related expenses near 82% of revenue for 2020. Inman also noted that Compass declined to comment on agent splits.
That figure is an estimate across the whole company, not an agent’s split. It tells you little about your own schedule.
Ownership has also changed. The Real Deal’s January 2026 report says the $1.6 billion Anywhere deal closed months ahead of schedule. The acquired brands will keep operating independently, so terms may differ.
The lesson is practical. Ask your manager for your full schedule in writing, including tiers, caps, and fees. Then run the formula above.
For a wider view of the trade, read our guide to no-split versus traditional models.
One more point applies to every option here. A 100% plan is still a brokerage relationship, and your commission still flows through the broker.
Under Real Property Law section 442-a, a salesperson may not accept compensation from anyone but a licensed broker.

1. SPiRALNY: 100% commission with the support still attached
Fair warning: SPiRALNY is our brokerage, so we have a stake in this list. We show its fees as published, including the ones that make us look pricier.
SPiRALNY’s Platinum plan lets agents keep 100% of each commission and pay a flat monthly brokerage fee. It is a New York brokerage led by founder and principal broker Marcel Bellucci. It also serves buyers, sellers, renters, and landlords.
The pitch is the combination of 100% commission, brokerage support, and flexibility. For the local version, see the Manhattan 100% commission page.
The cost
The Platinum plan is $479 a month ($399 plan, $25 E&O, $55 technology), plus a $250 one-time onboarding fee. Year one totals $5,998. With the 4% checkout fee, that becomes $6,237.92.
Plans run month to month, and you can cancel anytime. Transaction fees and caps are not published, so ask to see the agreement before you commit. We would not call this plan free, and neither should you.
Realtor board and MLS fees are separate. They are required in some locations and optional in others.
What is included
Support is the same on the 90% and 100% plans. It covers transaction guidance, compliance oversight, marketing and operational help, direct broker access, mentorship, and training. Weekly Zoom trainings, a training library, mentor matching, and shadowing are part of it.
Agents use The SPiRALNY Cloud, the firm’s platform and CRM, for deals and communication. You can work from anywhere, and an office is open at 575 Fifth Avenue. SPiRALNY also covers your CE license renewal at no cost when you join.
Payouts arrive by direct deposit, typically the same or next business day after closing. The site also promises buyer, renter, and seller leads. Distribution varies by plan, production, and availability.
The 100% commission brokerage page lists the full plan details.
Strengths and limits
The main strength is the bundle. You keep 100% of the commission and still get mentorship, training, and broker access. The path from parking to 90% to 100% also lets you stay at one brokerage as your business changes.
The main limit is price, since McKee and Mont Sky both publish lower first-year costs. Mont Sky’s $399 includes E&O with no separate software fee. SPiRALNY’s $479 adds E&O and technology to its $399 plan.
Track record
Agent testimonials on the site center on mentorship, weekly training, and the 90% to 100% split. A Google rating widget on the site shows “Excellent” across 96 reviews. Many of those are consumer reviews of individual agents.
SPiRALNY does not publish a verified agent count, so we will not quote one.
2. McKee Realty: The lowest published fee
McKee Realty is a Brooklyn-based brokerage serving New York City and the state. Its Preferred plan is the 100% option. The page describes it as “for agents who want maximum leverage.”
The cost
The 100% plan is $140 a month plus a $200 one-time onboarding fee. That is $1,880 in year one and $1,680 a year after. McKee states “no other fees, no transaction fees” on the plan.
E&O insurance is included, and technology is not billed as a separate line. The page does not mention a commission cap either way, so confirm that in writing. It carries no “last updated” date, so treat the prices as a snapshot.
What is included
Every McKee plan includes the agent dashboard, marketing and AI automation, and transaction coordination. The firm also sells a 90/10 plan at $50 a month and an 85/15 plan at $0 a month. That ladder lets you move between tiers without changing firms.
Strengths and limits
McKee wins on cost and clarity. Against a brokerage that keeps 20%, its fees break even at $9,400 in gross commission.
The plan pages do not mention leads, mentorship, or in-person training. The pitch is platform and economics. If you want a mentor on call, ask what McKee offers before you join.
Track record
McKee does not publish an agent count or agent testimonials on the pages we read. Ask for references from current agents.
3. Mont Sky Real Estate: 100% with E&O and leads included
Mont Sky Real Estate is a New York City brokerage. Its page offers two choices. You can keep 100% for $399 a month, or keep 75% for $129 a month.
The page recommends the 100% plan for agents who close two or more deals a year by themselves. The 75% plan is for agents who close fewer than that.
The cost
The 100% plan costs $399 a month, or $4,788 a year. Mont Sky lists no startup fee and says dues are billed every 30 days. It also says there are no hidden transaction, desk, or software fees.
E&O coverage is described as complimentary and automatic. That makes Mont Sky $80 a month cheaper than SPiRALNY for the same 100% split. Mont Sky does not state a commission cap.
What is included
Experienced agents get access to a proprietary lead platform for verified buyer and seller leads. New agents can partner with senior agents. Leads go to a team channel, and management may assign them based on workload and proximity.
Volume is not guaranteed. The page says there will generally be activity every week, but it varies with the market. Training and optional mentorship are also listed.
Strengths and limits
Mont Sky pairs a lower price with a lead program. That is hard to match on paper.
Two cautions apply. Plan changes require six months’ written notice, which limits your flexibility. The page’s metadata shows a last-modified date of 12 March 2025, so confirm the price directly.
In our 2 October 2026 read, the firm described itself as fully remote. There is no office to visit.
Track record
Mont Sky does not publish an agent count on the page we read. Its lead promise carries the same caveat as any lead program, because volume cannot be forecast.

4. Royalux Realty: Branding and an annual fee
Royalux Realty is a New York City brokerage run by Johnie and Sophie. They say they have worked with agents since 2015. Its commission page lists three plans.
Plan A is 90/10 for $1,500 a year. Plan B is 95/5 for $2,000 a year. Plan C is 100% for $7,500 a year, or about $625 a month.
The cost
For a 100% split from day one, Plan C costs $7,500 a year. Against a brokerage that keeps 20%, that breaks even at $37,500 in gross commission. It is the highest flat annual fee in this guide.
There is another route to 100%. Plans A and B have a hard annual cap of $10,000. After you contribute $10,000 in a calendar year, you keep 100%.
The page does not say whether the annual fee counts toward that cap.
The page also does not state E&O, technology, onboarding, or transaction fees. Ask for all four in writing.
What is included
Royalux lists training and support, tailor-made branding materials, and team-building strategies. It also offers about 200 hours of on-demand training videos. Free printing, a workstation, and a listing-upload service are included.
The firm offers a path to become a franchisee. In our 2 October 2026 read, its pages also described a free weekly training and Q&A program.
Strengths and limits
Royalux stands out for branding. It is the only firm here that leads with branded materials and a franchise path.
Its pages are inconsistent, so treat every number as unconfirmed. The commission page carries a 2023 copyright.
On 2 October 2026, the About page described a “no annual fee” 90/10 split with a $10,000 cap. Confirm which version is current before you sign.
Track record
Royalux does not publish an agent count. Ask the owners for references from agents on the plan you are considering.

5. Alpha Properties NYC: A desk in a small office
Alpha Properties NYC is a small, office-based firm at 10 East 23rd Street. Its FAQ says it was founded in 1993 and has about a dozen agents. Each agent gets a desk, a computer, and a phone.
All of these details come from our 2 October 2026 read. Treat them as stale.
The cost
Alpha Pro 1 costs $499 a month, plus $360 per rental and $1,000 per sale. The page opens with a note asking agents to contact the firm because some policies have changed. Its worked examples date from 2013 and 2018, and some use a $399 figure.
At $499 a month, the base cost is $5,988 a year. Deal fees come on top. With four sales and six rentals, they add $6,160, for $12,148 in total.
The page does not state E&O, technology, or onboarding fees, or a commission cap. Ask for all four in writing.
Alpha Pro 2 is a different structure. It pays 70% with no monthly or transaction fees until $100,000 in gross commission, then 100%. A “100%” headline at Alpha is not comparable with a flat-fee model, because transaction charges apply.
What is included
Agents get a desk, one-on-one training, and a small-office setting. The firm may reimburse real estate school after an agent’s tenth deal. Payment is made on request once a deal is fully closed.
Strengths and limits
Alpha suits an agent who wants a physical office and a very small team. The recruiting incentive is unusual. The Pro 2 ceiling falls by $1,000 for each agent you recruit.
It is a weaker like-for-like match for the cloud-based firms here. Its pricing is the least current on this list.
Track record
Alpha reports about a dozen agents and no testimonials on the page we read. Call the firm to confirm current terms before you compare.
Common questions about leaving Compass for 100%
Does Compass offer a 100% commission plan?
Compass does not publish a standard split or a 100% option in the sources we reviewed. Terms may differ by agent and by brand. Ask your manager for your schedule in writing.
Is a 100% brokerage always cheaper than a split?
No. A flat fee wins only above your break-even point. At a 20% brokerage share, McKee breaks even at $9,400 in gross commission and SPiRALNY at $29,990.
Below those numbers, a split may cost you less. Use your last twelve months, not your best quarter.
What costs hide behind “100%”?
Look for monthly and annual fees, onboarding, E&O, technology, and per-transaction charges. Some firms add card processing fees. SPiRALNY’s checkout adds a 4% platform fee.
Realtor board and MLS fees may apply too, and they vary by location. Ask each firm for a full fee schedule in writing.
Do I still need a broker on a 100% plan?
Yes. A 100% plan is a brokerage relationship, and your commission is paid through your broker. The broker of record stays responsible for supervising your work.
Will my listings and clients follow me?
Not automatically. Your independent contractor agreement governs listings and pending deals. Many firms treat listings as the broker’s property.
Read the agreement before you resign. Ask an attorney if it limits contact after you leave.
When does SPiRALNY’s 100% plan beat its 90% plan?
The 100% plan costs $300 more each month, or $3,600 a year. That equals the 10% you save at $36,000 in gross commission a year. Above that, the 100% plan comes out ahead, before the card fee.
Conclusion: let your own statement pick the winner
Choose McKee if you self-source and want the lowest published fee. Choose Mont Sky if you want E&O and a lead program in one price, after you confirm its current terms.
Choose SPiRALNY if you want 100% commission with mentorship, training, and direct broker access. Choose Royalux if branding and a franchise path matter. Choose Alpha only after you confirm its current terms.
Ready to run your own numbers? Pull your last twelve months of statements and test them against the tables above. If support matters as much as the split, SPiRALNY’s Platinum plan takes about five minutes to join online. You can cancel anytime if it is not the right fit.




